Pacifiers For Newborns: When And Why To Introduce Them

Pacifiers are often used to calm and soothe babies, and they can be beneficial in this regard. However, the ideal time to introduce a pacifier to a newborn is debated. While some sources state that there is no minimum age for using a pacifier, others recommend waiting until the baby is at least 3-4 weeks old to avoid potential problems with breastfeeding and weight gain. Introducing a pacifier too early can cause nipple confusion, making babies uncomfortable when feeding from the breast and interfering with successful breastfeeding. Therefore, it is generally recommended to first ensure that the baby can nurse well and that the mother's milk supply is established before introducing a pacifier, which typically occurs around four to six weeks after birth.

Pacifiers can be used from birth, but it is recommended to wait until breastfeeding is established

While some parents feel judged for relying on a pacifier, there is no need to feel guilty. Pacifiers have many benefits, including soothing babies, helping them fall asleep at night, and potentially reducing the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).

However, if you are breastfeeding, it is recommended to wait until your baby is feeding well before introducing a pacifier. Sucking is a natural, soothing instinct that drives your baby to eat. If you're breastfeeding, this sucking reflex also helps to establish your milk supply. So, if you're breastfeeding and want to offer your newborn a pacifier, make sure to feed your baby on demand first.

It is understandable that comforting your baby is a priority. However, their nutrition must be your top priority. A newborn needs their mother's milk as their complete source of nutrition, especially in their first few months. This means that for a mother's milk supply to be established for the following months, the baby must suckle frequently at the breast. This establishes milk production and trains the baby to nurse well. Giving a pacifier while the baby is still learning to latch may interfere with the breastfeeding process.

Therefore, it is best to introduce artificial nipples around four to six weeks after birth, when the baby is observed to be good at sucking on the breast already. By this time, the mother's milk supply should be well established (usually around 6-8 weeks), and the 6-week growth spurt is over.

Pacifiers can help soothe and calm newborns

Pacifiers can be a great way to help soothe and calm newborns. While some babies are easily calmed by rocking or cuddling, others just can't seem to get enough suckling, even after they've been fed. This is where a pacifier comes in handy, as it satisfies their sucking reflex.

There is no minimum age for using a pacifier, and they are even used in NICUs for non-nutritive sucking and comfort. However, it is recommended to wait at least 3-4 weeks before introducing a pacifier to a newborn, especially if you are breastfeeding. This is because, during the early weeks, infants can get all their vitamin D from their mother's milk, and introducing a pacifier too early can cause "nipple confusion", leading to problems with breastfeeding. It is important to ensure that your baby is gaining weight and nursing well before offering a pacifier.

Pacifiers have several benefits, including:

• Soothing and calming fussy babies
• Helping babies fall asleep
• Reducing the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)
• Helping preterm infants feed and gain weight
• Easier to discontinue compared to thumb-sucking

However, there are also some disadvantages to using pacifiers. They include:

• Increased risk of middle ear infections
• Potential for addiction, causing dependence on the pacifier
• Dental problems if used regularly for more than a few years
• Potential for "nipple confusion" and interference with breastfeeding

They can also help with establishing a sucking reflex in preterm infants

Pacifiers are often used to calm and soothe babies during their fussy periods. They are also used to satisfy a baby's sucking reflex, which is a natural, soothing instinct that drives a baby to eat.

Pacifiers are even used in NICUs to help preterm infants establish a sucking reflex, which in turn improves feeding and weight gain. This is because sucking stimulates the release of hormones from the brain that reduce stress and soothe the baby.

However, it is recommended that pacifiers and other artificial nipples be avoided for at least the first 3-4 weeks of a newborn's life, especially if the mother intends to breastfeed. This is because, in the first few weeks, parents are still getting to know their baby's hunger cues and are also trying to establish breastfeeding or bottle-feeding. Introducing a pacifier too early can cause "nipple confusion", making babies uncomfortable when feeding from the breast, which interferes with successful breastfeeding and usually results in a decrease in the mother's milk supply.

Therefore, it is recommended that a baby should first be able to nurse well before being given any kind of artificial nipple. This usually occurs about 4-6 weeks after birth, once breastfeeding is going smoothly and the mother's milk supply is established.

Pacifiers should not be used as a substitute for feedings

While pacifiers can be a source of comfort for newborns, they should not be used as a substitute for feedings. Here are some reasons why:

Nutrition Comes First

A newborn's complete source of nutrition is their mother's milk, especially in their first few months. For a mother's milk supply to be established, the baby must frequently suckle on the breast. This not only establishes milk production but also trains the baby to nurse well. Giving a pacifier while the baby is still learning to latch can interfere with the breastfeeding process and may result in a decrease in milk supply.

Nipple Confusion

Introducing a pacifier too early can lead to "nipple confusion". This condition occurs when babies are introduced to feeding bottles or pacifiers very early and then become uncomfortable when feeding from the breast. As a result, successful breastfeeding is hindered, and the baby may not get the nutrition they need.

Weight Gain Concerns

If a baby is having problems gaining weight, it is best to avoid giving them a pacifier. Breastfeeding or bottle-feeding should be prioritised to ensure the baby is getting adequate nutrition and gaining weight appropriately.

Potential Feeding Problems

Introducing a pacifier too early when a baby is being breastfed can cause some babies to become content with sucking on the pacifier and not feed when they need to. This can impact their nutrition and overall health.

Dental Problems

Prolonged pacifier use, especially if used regularly for more than a few years, can affect the development of a child's bite and teeth. It can lead to dental issues such as cavities, gum recession, and crooked teeth. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry recommends stopping pacifier use after a baby turns one year old.

In conclusion, while pacifiers can be useful for soothing and comforting newborns, they should not be used as a substitute for feedings. It is important to prioritise a baby's nutrition and overall health by ensuring they are fed adequately and frequently, especially in the early months when breastfeeding is being established.

There are potential disadvantages to using pacifiers, including dental problems and ear infections

While pacifiers can be a great tool for soothing newborns and infants, there are some potential disadvantages associated with their use, particularly when it comes to dental problems and ear infections.

Dental problems, often referred to as "pacifier teeth", can arise from prolonged pacifier use. The longer a child uses a pacifier, the more likely they are to experience issues such as an open bite, buck teeth, crossbites, and changes to the roof of their mouth. These issues can lead to orthodontic treatment being required later in life. Additionally, gum loss and cavities can occur if parents dip pacifiers in sweet substances, exposing their child's teeth and gums to sugar.

It is recommended that parents discourage pacifier use after the age of three to prevent these dental issues from occurring. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry has found that the risk of bite issues starts to increase from 12-18 months of age.

Ear infections are another common issue associated with pacifier use. Several studies have shown a clear increase in the risk of ear infections, particularly acute otitis media, in children who use pacifiers. The risk is up to three times higher for continual pacifier users compared to non-users, and there appears to be a "dose response" relationship, with occasional users having a lower risk.

To reduce the chances of ear infections, it is recommended that parents restrict pacifier use to when their child is falling asleep. Maintaining proper hygiene practices and using the appropriately-sized pacifier for your child's age can also help mitigate the risks associated with pacifier use.

Frequently asked questions